Dr. Jaksa is a Professor of Teacher Education at Saginaw Valley State University in Michigan and immediate Past Chair of the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education. She also serves on the Board of Directors of the Council for the Accreditation of Educator Preparation.
She has led a national team of educators, teacher educators, researchers and educational leaders in developing a birth–kindergarten science and engineering framework, bringing her commitment to curiosity, wonder and meaningful science learning to the earliest years of education.
She has also written about how teachers can encourage curiosity, what AI can and can’t do in the classroom, and how to make digital learning work for more students. In 2026, she co-authored books on digital learning, AI in teacher education and partnerships between schools and families.
What has surprised me most is not simply how quickly AI has developed but how profoundly it is challenging us to reconsider what learning means. For years, educators have encouraged students to find information, organize ideas and produce thoughtful responses. Now AI can perform many of those tasks in seconds. That raises an important question: When a student produces an excellent answer with AI assistance, what has the student actually learned?
I see tremendous possibilities. AI can help educators develop thoughtful, standards-aligned instructional materials, provide timely, targeted feedback, and offer students additional ways to engage with difficult concepts. At the same time, I am mindful of the risk that students may bypass the very intellectual work that helps them grow.
Importantly, I do not believe that using AI and thinking critically are mutually exclusive. AI is already part of our students' world and will undoubtedly shape their futures. Our responsibility as educators is to prepare them to engage with it thoughtfully, ethically and confidently.
That means explicitly teaching AI literacy and responsible digital citizenship. Students need to learn how to ask meaningful questions, construct thoughtful prompts, recognize the limitations and potential biases of AI systems, verify information and critically evaluate the responses they receive. They also need to understand privacy, academic integrity, and when it is appropriate to use AI and when their own independent thinking is essential. The challenge is not to keep AI out of education. It is to design learning experiences in which students learn both to think independently and to think critically with AI, using it to deepen curiosity, reflection, creativity and understanding rather than simply generate answers.
Perhaps the most important question is no longer just “What can AI do?” but “How can we teach students to use AI responsibly while ensuring that the thinking, judgment and learning remain their own?”
I think instructors need to understand that AI integration is fundamentally a pedagogical decision, not simply a technological one. Before adopting a tool, we should ask: What do I want students to know, understand and be able to do? How does this tool align with our learning objectives and relevant educational standards? What intellectual work should students do themselves? Where might AI provide meaningful support, and where might it interfere with learning?
We also need to recognize that teachers and university instructors cannot be expected to navigate these questions through occasional workshops alone. As we discussed during the recent international webinar, professional learning must become a continuous part of educational practice. That means research-based, standards-aligned professional development, opportunities to collaborate and communities of practice where educators can share what works, examine what does not and learn from one another. AI will continue to change. Our professional learning systems must be capable of changing with it.
Most importantly, I want instructors to recognize that their professional judgment, relationships with students and understanding of how people learn are becoming more important, not less.
The Curiosity Cycle grew out of my belief that wonder and curiosity are fundamental to learning. Children are naturally curious, and I believe our responsibility as educators is to nurture that curiosity throughout their lives, including in higher education.
In my work, I've developed a four-phase model: Provocation, Questioning, Exploration, and Reflection. Although it emerged from elementary science education, I believe it translates beautifully into a college classroom.
For example, imagine I'm teaching a university course for future elementary teachers. Instead of beginning a lesson on scientific inquiry with a lecture about the scientific method, I might place several ice cubes in different conditions: one on metal, one on wood and one wrapped in fabric, and ask students, “What do you notice? What do you wonder?”
That's the Provocation. It sparks curiosity before I introduce formal explanations.
Next comes Questioning. Students might wonder why ice melts faster on one surface than another. Together, we'd refine those observations into questions they could actually investigate.
During Exploration, small groups would design and conduct their own investigations, collect evidence and discuss what their results suggest. My role would be to guide their thinking, not simply give them the answer.
Finally, during Reflection, students would revisit their original predictions, explain what the evidence revealed and consider how their thinking changed.
But because these are future teachers, I'd add one more layer: I'd ask them to reflect on the learning experience itself. How did it feel to begin with wonder rather than a lecture? What did the instructor do to support their questions? And how could they create that same experience for children?
That's what I find so powerful about the Curiosity Cycle. It doesn't just help students learn science. It helps future teachers experience the kind of learning we hope they'll create for their own students. And perhaps most importantly, reflection often leads to new questions, so the cycle begins again. Curiosity doesn't end when we find an answer. Very often, that's where the next discovery begins.
I believe the greatest difference comes when we move beyond thinking of access as simply providing a device or an Internet connection and begin thinking about access to meaningful, high-quality learning opportunities. Students may experience barriers related to disability, language, geography, economic circumstances or differences in prior educational opportunity. Digital technologies can help reduce some of these barriers by providing accessible materials, flexible pathways for engaging with content and multiple ways for students to demonstrate what they know and can do.
But technology alone does not create equity or inclusion. Thoughtful, standards-aligned curriculum design, accessible learning environments and sustained professional learning for educators are essential. One example I discussed during our recent GSENet webinar was the University of Michigan Center for Digital Curricula's Roadmap initiative, which emphasizes deeply digital curriculum and sustained teacher support. What I find particularly important about this work is the recognition that meaningful educational improvement requires more than introducing new tools. It requires coherent instructional design, ongoing support for teachers and careful attention to student learning.
Thoughtfully designed digital learning environments can also provide scaffolding that responds to students' individual needs, helping them work through challenging concepts, address gaps in understanding and gradually develop greater independence. An emerging example is the centre's RoadmapBot, which is being developed to provide AI-supported scaffolding and targeted instructional support. The promise of such approaches lies not simply in providing students with answers but in helping them build the understanding and confidence to progress in their learning.
For me, the guiding question is not simply whether students have access to technology, but whether that technology genuinely expands their opportunities to participate, develop confidence, exercise agency and succeed.
Equity in digital learning is not just about access to technology. It is about access to meaningful learning.
I believe this is one of the most important questions educators and families should be asking.
In my Education Week article, AI Can Read to Our Children. That Doesn't Mean It Should, I introduced the idea of a “lullaby crisis,” a cultural shift in which we increasingly allow machines to perform the quiet acts of care that have traditionally helped define parenting and teaching.
When a parent reads a bedtime story or a teacher responds patiently to a child's question, something much more meaningful than the delivery of information is happening. There is shared attention, emotional connection, trust and responsiveness. These interactions are fundamental to children's development and learning.
AI can simulate the sounds of warmth and attentiveness, but it cannot form the human relationships that children need. I think we should apply that same question to AI tutoring, feedback, assessment and even the ways students seek help in the classroom.
For example, AI can provide immediate feedback, generate explanations and offer personalized practice. Those capabilities can be genuinely valuable, especially when they help educators meet diverse learning needs. But we should be concerned if students begin turning primarily to AI rather than to parents, teachers and peers for guidance, encouragement and meaningful conversation.
A teacher notices when a student is discouraged, recognizes an unexpected spark of curiosity and understands how a learner's experiences may influence their thinking. These human dimensions of teaching should not be treated as inefficiencies that technology needs to eliminate. In my article, I suggested three principles for responsible AI integration: human-centred design, keeping educators and caregivers central to decisions, and continued investment in people.
For me, the guiding question is whether AI strengthens the relationships and learning experiences that matter most, or whether it quietly begins to replace them. The danger is not that artificial intelligence is too capable. It is that we may begin to expect less of ourselves.
Technology can support teaching and learning in extraordinary ways. But efficiency should never come at the expense of human presence. Ultimately, education is not simply about delivering information. It is about nurturing people, their curiosity, their confidence and their capacity to grow.
I think we must begin by distinguishing between evidence that AI is being used and evidence that students are genuinely learning. Students may complete assignments more quickly or produce more polished work with AI assistance, but those outcomes alone do not demonstrate deeper understanding.
We need to ask whether students can explain their thinking, apply what they have learned to new situations, evaluate evidence, solve problems and demonstrate understanding independently when appropriate. This is where alignment with learning objectives and educational standards becomes especially important. We should be clear about what students are expected to know and be able to do and then gather meaningful evidence of their progress.
AI may help educators identify learning patterns, develop formative assessments or provide timely feedback. However, its outputs and recommendations also need to be evaluated for accuracy, fairness and educational relevance.
I would encourage instructors to look at multiple forms of evidence: student work, classroom discussion, formative assessment, student reflection and demonstrated learning over time. We should also ask whether the benefits extend to students who have historically experienced barriers to educational opportunity.
Ultimately, the question is not simply whether AI helped students produce better work. It is whether students became more knowledgeable, thoughtful, capable and independent learners. The quality of an AI-generated product should never be mistaken for the quality of the learning that produced it.
I would encourage instructors to begin their next class with a meaningful question rather than an immediate explanation. Present students with a scenario, a surprising finding or a problem that invites curiosity. Ask them what they notice, what they wonder and what additional information they would need to develop a thoughtful response. Give students time to think independently and then discuss their ideas with a partner or small group.
If AI is appropriate to the learning objective, invite students to use it as a tool for extending their inquiry. For example, they might ask AI to offer an alternative explanation, identify a counterargument or suggest a question they had not considered. Then ask students to evaluate the response. Is it accurate? What evidence supports it? What assumptions might it contain? What did the students themselves contribute to the process? I would conclude by inviting students to reflect on how their thinking changed and what questions remain.
This small instructional shift can help students recognize that learning is not simply about arriving at an answer. It involves asking meaningful questions, examining evidence, considering different perspectives and developing the confidence to make informed judgments.
My hope is that we create classrooms in which curiosity, critical thinking and student agency are not occasional outcomes but intentional parts of everyday learning.
One of the most influential educators in my life was Dr. Leonard “Len” Kaplan, my dissertation chair at Wayne State University. Len was an extraordinary mentor whose work on affective questioning and the relationship between emotion and cognition profoundly shaped my understanding of teaching and learning.
His work, Asking the Next Question, was particularly inspirational. Len encouraged his students to ask meaningful questions and then follow those questions with others that would help them better understand a learner's thinking. For him, questioning was not simply a way to check for understanding. It was a way to deepen thinking, encourage reflection and connect with learners.
Interestingly, Len was not particularly enthusiastic about technology. But he taught me something that I believe is even more important in today's technology-rich educational environment: The quality of our questions matters, and the next question can be just as important as the first.
I see his influence in my own Curiosity Cycle, which emphasizes wonder, questioning, exploration and reflection. As I consider the role of artificial intelligence in education, I continue to return to his emphasis on thoughtful questioning and the human relationships that make learning meaningful.
Although Asking the Next Question is currently out of print, I am working to bring it back into publication, updating its ideas to address contemporary educational challenges and opportunities, including artificial intelligence. I believe Len's insights about affective questioning, cognition and understanding how students think are just as relevant today as when he first wrote them. In an era when AI can provide answers almost instantaneously, the ability to ask the next meaningful question may be more important than ever.
Another scholar whose work has deeply influenced my thinking is Lev Vygotsky. His sociocultural theory reminds us that learning is shaped by social interaction, language and cultural context. His concept of the zone of proximal development is especially meaningful because it helps explain the importance of providing appropriate support as learners develop new knowledge and skills.
This connects closely to instructional scaffolding. Effective teachers recognize what students can do independently, provide guidance when needed and gradually reduce that support as students develop greater understanding, confidence and independence.
I see important implications for the thoughtful integration of AI. Technology can help provide scaffolding, offer feedback and support students as they work through challenging concepts. But we must be intentional about how that support is designed. The goal should not be to make students dependent on technology or simply provide answers. It should be to strengthen their thinking and help them become increasingly independent learners.
I would encourage readers to explore Kaplan's Asking the Next Question, Vygotsky's work on learning and development, and contemporary frameworks for human-centred AI in education. What connects these influences for me is a belief that learning is both an intellectual and a deeply human experience. Students need opportunities to ask questions, develop understanding, experience encouragement and learn through meaningful relationships.
As we embrace new technologies, I believe we must remember that the most important question is not simply what technology can do for learners but how it can help us become better educators and help our students become more thoughtful, curious and independent thinkers.
We use cookies on this site to enhance your user experience
By clicking "Accept" you agree to practices outlined in our Privacy Policy